The advent calendar is a loyalty scheme in a box

Hand-drawn advent calendar door number 2, covered in snowflakes, with a padlock hanging on it.

This year there’s an advent calendar for everything. The one that made them famous works because of what happens in the other eleven months.

In two weeks, most of the country will open the first little cardboard door. Ipsos reckons 72% of us buy an advent calendar. Most are chocolate. A growing number are not.

This year there’s one for everything. Dog treats. Cheese. Jam. A £100 one from Porsche. An £860 one from Wedgwood. Somebody, somewhere, has made one full of vapes. If 2026 has a retail format, it’s twenty-four doors and a ribbon.

So it’s worth asking whether it actually works. Not for the people opening the doors. For the brands making them.

Behind door number one

The calendar everyone points to is Liberty’s.

Liberty didn’t invent the beauty advent calendar. Selfridges, for one, says it got there first, a few years earlier. But Liberty’s is the one that turned a novelty into an event. At launch it sold one every two minutes. It’s the fastest-selling product in the shop’s roughly 150-year history, and Liberty says it has sold out eleven years in a row.

This year’s costs £285 and, by Liberty’s count, holds over £1,300 of product. That’s the bit everyone copies: the box, the claimed value, the countdown.

It isn’t the bit that makes it work.

What’s actually behind the door

Look at how Liberty sells it.

The first chance to buy goes to members of Beauty Drop, Liberty’s beauty subscription. Members pay £25 a month and get £20 of it back every month as credit to spend on anything in the shop, plus four seasonal beauty boxes a year. Among the perks Liberty lists: early access to the advent calendar, with £25 off. And in 2023 Liberty said a portion of its members had saved their credit all year to buy one.

So for its best customers the calendar isn’t really a Christmas product. It’s the reward at the end of a twelve-month relationship. Some of them are effectively paying for it in March.

Run that through the funnel and it lights up in the places most marketing never reaches. Returns: a reason to stay subscribed all year. Preaches: the queue, the sold-out headlines, the unboxing videos. And the sold-out story becomes the Notices moment for everyone who missed out, which is a fine way to recruit next year’s subscribers.

It works because of what happens in the other eleven months.

Everyone else

Now picture the same box from a brand without that relationship behind it.

It goes on sale in the autumn, to people who mostly haven’t bought from you before. If it sells, that’s one purchase. No subscription, no credit, nothing that brings them back on the 26th. In funnel terms, it’s a single Buys moment with a ribbon on.

And if it doesn’t sell, there’s a hard deadline. An advent calendar bought on the 5th of December is already four doors behind. Retailers need them gone by about the 2nd, or they start cutting. Last December, Which? was flagging 30% off a department store fragrance calendar and Lego calendars at nearly half price.

Even the biggest names get this wrong. Last week Skims, Kim Kardashian’s $5bn shapewear brand, offered refunds on its $148 (£110) twelve-day calendar after TikTok worked out what was behind the doors. Three days of hair ties. Three days of Skims-logo hair clips. Several keychains. People started emptying out their sofas and claiming they’d accidentally made the Skims calendar. The company admitted that “for some, the calendar didn’t meet expectations.” The box was there. The reason to open it wasn’t.

The usual defence is sampling: get your products into new hands. But when YouGov asked people why they buy advent calendars, only 8% said it was to try new products. Most people buy them as a treat, from brands they already like. Which is the Liberty model again, just without the subscription that makes it pay.

When it does work

There’s a version that isn’t about loyalty. Lookfantastic launched a calendar in 2015 with 1,000 units and says it hit 165,000 by 2025. Bonne Maman’s has sold out eight years running.

For those brands the calendar isn’t a side product. It’s the front door: the thing people know them for, and the way new customers find the range. That’s a different job, and it only works if the calendar is genuinely the best way into the brand, not one of 128 on a department store shelf.

Before you build one

Three questions before anyone signs off a calendar:

  1. Who is it for? People who already love you, or people who’ve never heard of you? Be honest. Only one of those groups buys advent calendars in any number.
  2. What happens on the 26th? If the answer is nothing, you’ve made a very expensive sample pack.
  3. What’s the plan for the 2nd of December? Because if it hasn’t sold by then, the plan is a discount.

Liberty didn’t build an advent calendar. It built a reason to stay, and put a calendar at the end of it.

What’s the box your business keeps copying, without the year behind it?

Sources: Liberty, The Beauty Drop terms (Nov 2026); Ipsos (Sept 2025); YouGov (Nov 2024); Liberty, Retail Times and Woman & Home on Liberty’s calendar and Beauty Drop (2025–26); Retail Gazette (2023) and Reuters (2022) on Selfridges and the calendar boom; THG on Lookfantastic (2025); Modern Retail on Bonne Maman (2025); Which? advent calendar deals (Dec 2025); BBC on Skims (Nov 2026); The Guardian (2023, 2025).